Superior Court Update (August 12)

A Superior Court Update for the week of August 12, 2021, a follow-up to the recent Court ruling. As ordered by the Court, the plaintiffs in the various actions regarding approvals for construction of a hotel at 20 Central Street filed a new, comprehensive brief. On August 12 attorney for the plaintiffs, Kristin Collins, filed a brief outlining the key claims citing legal precedent, legislative records, State Attorney General opinions, and more.

The key elements of the case remain that the Planning Board erred in various ways in their role enforcing the Land Use Ordinance. Key among these are enforcement of the parking requirements, architectural standards, and preservation of scenic views. The brief also outlines the failure of the town to enforce the ordinance changes approved by the voters in August 2020 citing both a Constitutional argument and the fact that the building permit was not issued until six months after the changes. Finally, the brief addresses the Code Enforcement Officer’s error in application of various provisions of the Land Use Ordinance, many repeating Planning Board errors. These errors include architectural standards, consistency with plans approved by the Planning Board, and others.

Simply driving, walking or biking past the construction site on Central Street one can now clearly see the incongruity of the new building vis-a-vis the historic neighboring properties. The town and 20 Central Street LLC have until August 26 to submit their brief to the Court. We will continue to keep you apprised with a new Superior Court Update at that time.